top of page
  • Writer's pictureRoy Reema

Book Review: The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck- Overhyped and Cliched.

Updated: Dec 23, 2023

Imagine flipping the script on self-help and saying, “Enough with the relentless positivity, it’s time to embrace life’s struggles!” Now, doesn’t that sound intriguing? Well, that’s precisely what Mark Manson’s book “The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck” brings to the table. The book challenges the traditional self-help concepts and provides a fresh, albeit counterintuitive, perspective on leading a fulfilling life. Buckle up, folks, as we dive deep into the world of Mark Manson’s unique take on self-improvement.


Manson's Writing.

Manson's central thesis revolves around the liberating concept of selectively investing our cares and energies. The book navigates through the nuances of human experiences, urging readers to embrace their limitations and accept the less glamorous realities of life. This raw and unfiltered narrative style, woven with personal anecdotes and edgy humour, may have the power to resonate with readers seeking a less traditional approach to personal development. While some readers appreciate his blunt, no-nonsense approach, others find it abrasive and off-putting. His use of strong language can be seen as an attempt to be edgy and relatable, but it often comes off as forced and unnecessary. Additionally, his tendency to oversimplify complex issues can be misleading and fails to provide a comprehensive understanding of the topics he discusses.


Mark Manson's Counterintuitive Approach

In “The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck”, Manson suggests that life’s struggles give it meaning. The book offers practical ways to embrace challenges and find value in them, opposing the usual positivity that is often served in self-help books.

The underpinning philosophy of the book is that true strength, joy, and freedom come from figuring out what’s worth caring about and what’s not. This unique perspective on self-improvement has resonated with many readers worldwide. Instead of stressing about life's imperfections, Manson advises focusing on stuff that really counts for a meaningful life.


The Subtle Art of not Giving a Fuck
Kindle view of book

The Importance of Choosing What to Care About

The core of Manson’s strategy revolves around deciding what deserves our attention. He emphasizes making smart choices about what’s important and sticking to those choices. Manson believes that solving problems brings happiness and promotes resilience. He strongly advises against falling into a victim mindset and emphasizes that there are only so many things we can truly care about.

Manson encourages us to question our control over the outcome, the nature of the problems it brings, and its alignment with our core values. It’s about focusing on the good stuff and the things that matter. This approach helps us figure out what’s important and pushes us to become better and lead a more satisfying life. This is where Manson’s book differs from the common ‘you’re awesome’ vibe in self-help. He’s all about focusing on what really counts for you and not sweating the small stuff, leading to a more fulfilling and rich life.


Literary Criticism and Reception

Readers have responded positively to the book (especially the young readers). In many book review forums, the book has:

  • Resonated with readers, making them look at their lives from a completely different perspective

  • Sparked a multitude of discussions and debates due to its unique approach to self-help

Nonetheless, the book has faced its fair share of critique. Some readers have found the book’s deep dive into moral aspects overwhelming. There have been criticisms about the book losing its steam as it progresses and about its structure being confusing for some.


The Subtle Art of not Giving a Fuck book
Image of a book


Overall Impression

As I journeyed through the pages, it became apparent that Manson’s insights, though compelling, are not entirely groundbreaking. The book draws heavily from the roots of Buddhist philosophy and other self-help narratives, echoing the age-old wisdom that has been guiding humanity for centuries. There’s a sense of déjà vu for those familiar with Eastern philosophies or seasoned self-help readers. While Manson’s work is undeniably relatable, especially in its acknowledgement of life’s inherent struggles, it falls short of delivering a truly novel perspective.


The conversational tone sprinkled generously with profanities, might strike a chord with those seeking a blunt, no-nonsense guide to life. Yet, it’s important to discern that the book’s appeal largely stems from its controversial packaging rather than its core content. One could argue that the book is more a product of clever marketing – a testament to the age-old adage that sometimes, it’s not just about the message but how you sell it. (Of late, and sadly, this is how books are being sold these days; read more about it.) For readers steeped in the rich heritage of philosophical and spiritual literature, particularly from Eastern traditions, Manson’s book might not illuminate new pathways of thinking. It’s akin to revisiting familiar territories, albeit through a different lens – a lens tinted with modern cynicism and raw, unvarnished truths.


Conclusion

In my quest for wisdom and personal growth, I find myself drawn more to works that delve deeper into the human psyche and offer more substantive, transformative insights. In this regard, “Life’s Amazing Secrets” by Gaur Gopal Das stands out as a more profound and enriching read, one that I would recommend for a deeper exploration into life’s myriad truths.

In conclusion, while “The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck” may offer momentary solace and a few chuckles, its long-term value as a transformative self-help book is, in my view, limited. It’s a book that tells you what you already know, albeit in a bold and brash manner. For those seeking surface-level motivation with a touch of humour, Manson’s book could be a delightful read. But for those on a quest for deeper philosophical and existential insights, the journey might need to continue beyond the realms of this book.

In the realm of self-help literature, where the shelves are brimming with promises of transformation and self-actualisation, Mark Manson's “The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck” stands out – not just for its audaciously unapologetic title but also for its brazen approach to life’s complexities. As I delved into this book, I found myself on a journey that was both familiar and distinctive, reminiscent of the ancient wisdom of the East yet packaged with a modern, irreverent twist.


About the Author

Mark Manson started writing in 2007, blogging about dating on his wildly popular internet blog. This helped him share his tips on dating and self-improvement, build a fan base, and eventually publish some bestselling books.

His writing process is about storytelling and being passionate about his writing. He spends anywhere between 3-12 hours on his articles, sometimes with the help of his team at the writing centre. His openness to trying out new things and seeing what works has been instrumental in connecting with his readers and keeping them hooked. In fact, his approach has even caught the attention of publications like the Wall Street Journal.

Overall Rating: 2/5 For lack of novelty and delivery


Subscribe to the blog to get book reviews and other stories delivered to your inbox directly.

129 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page